Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Sunlit elevated entry with white stucco, silvered wood cladding, a closed glass door, limestone paving and a single sea grape specimen in a masonry planter.

Pensacola Beach Leasehold Property: A Buyer's Guide for 2026

"We recognize that this permit, and a few others that we recently issued on the island, should have included a clearer demonstration of riparian rights (also known as sufficient upland interest)." Elizabeth Orr, director of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection's Northwest Region, wrote that in an email on January 12, 2026. It was about a proposed private pier on Santa Rosa Sound near Baby Beach.

The email matters to anyone writing an offer on the island. The Pensacola News Journal reports that Pensacola Beach has no fee simple ownership. Land that isn't under lease is public. At closing, a buyer takes an assignment of a long-term lease from the Santa Rosa Island Authority, the agency that manages the county-owned land. The buyer doesn't get a deed to the ground. Over the past year, the SRIA board has argued in public about three terms of that lease: where it ends, what it costs each year, and how it renews. None of the three is fully settled as of October 2026. On this island, the lease is the property, and you should read it more closely than the listing.

Where the leasehold stops

The pier case shows how a soundfront home can look like it reaches the water when its lease doesn't. The SRIA board unanimously approved a Pier Amendment for the leasehold on December 17, 2025. Island Times reports that a Pier Amendment is one of the documents needed to permit a residential pier, and it sets the repair, insurance, use and maintenance terms. DEP had already issued its permit. The board then approved a walkover so the owners could reach the pier, and that walkover crossed land outside their lease.

Orr's email listed what would count as proof of sufficient upland interest. Speakers at the January 28 board meeting repeated the same three options:

  1. SRIA joins the DEP permit as co-applicant.
  2. SRIA revises the lease to extend the leasehold to the mean high water line.
  3. SRIA grants the leaseholder a riparian easement under the walkover.

Each of those options depends on a decision by the landowner, which is SRIA. The upland leaseholder doesn't hold the right on its own. Board member Elizabeth Timothy said the leaseholder had already spent more than $40,000 after getting "green light, green light, green light" from the permitting agencies. Board member Bruce Childers said he had talked with a coastal engineer who believed the pier would cause severe erosion at Baby Beach.

On January 28, a motion to rescind the approval failed on a 3–3 vote. Childers, Jeremy Johnson and chair Charles Thornton voted to rescind. Timothy, David Peaden and Jerry Watson voted no. The owners withdrew their request on February 2. Orr later wrote that DEP "does not consider this project fully compliant at this time." She also said her staff was reviewing other recently issued island permits.

The wider dispute is still open. Dianne Krumel of Save Pensacola Beach told the board that ordinances adopted after her 2018 campaign bar leasing any unleased land on the island. She argued that piers built after August 2, 2018 are illegal. Board attorney Mary Jane Bass told the board she didn't think it had done anything illegal. Timothy said she supported changing procedures going forward. Pier comments continued at the April 22 meeting. Even so, SRIA's records through the September 23, 2026 agenda show no new pier or riparian policy.

If you're buying a soundfront home that has a pier, or that you hope will have one, these are the questions to settle before closing. Does the lease carry a Pier Amendment? Was the DEP permit issued after 2018? Has SRIA documented any upland interest in the water's edge?

What the lease costs, and why two neighbors can pay very different amounts

The second term that changed is the annual fee. For years, SRIA collected 50% of the full annual lease fee, and that rate hadn't changed since 2003. Starting October 1, 2025, it collects 75%. The board voted 4–2 on June 23, 2025 to recommend the change. Timothy made the motion and Watson seconded. Johnson and Childers voted against it.

The increase came with a trade. SRIA agreed to pay Escambia County for full-time fire service at Station No. 13, about $2.4 million a year. In return, the county's beach fire-protection fee was expected to drop to zero. The Pensacola News Journal reported these ranges in July 2025:

Lease type Change under the 75% rate, effective Oct. 1, 2025
Single-family, full range Annual payments of $50.44 to $3,544.12
Single-family, 1,077 leases (76%) Increase of $16.81 to $201.73
Single-family, 238 leases Increase of $206.65 to $606.35
Single-family, 95 leases Increase of $674.12 to $1,181.37
Condo/multifamily, 605 leases (27%) Increase of $53.89 to $164.12 per unit
Condo/multifamily, 1,639 leases (72%) Increase of $206.65 to $375.50 per unit
Condo/multifamily, 39 leases (1%) Flat $538.50 per unit increase

Single-family payments run from about $50 to more than $3,500 a year because each fee comes from that specific lease, not from a schedule tied to the house. You can't estimate a home's fee from the house next door. You need the lease. Collections show the change took hold. In November 2025, commercial and residential lease fee collections totaled $449,787, which was 71% more than in November 2024.

The lease fee doesn't replace property tax. Escambia County's FY 2024/2025 budget message describes the island's 99-year leases as automatically renewable and says improvements on leasehold properties are taxable. Budget for both.

The SRIA board adopted its FY 2026/2027 budget 5–0 on July 1, 2026. It shifted $1 million from Gulfside to Soundside beach nourishment. The residential operating-revenue line stayed at $2,045,532, the same as the year before. On July 22, 2026, the board voted 6–0 to approve revisions to the Lease Fee Reduction Policy. That is the same policy that set the 75% collection rate, and the minutes don't say what the revisions changed. Before you rely on any fee figure, get the current billing for that specific lease from SRIA.

How long the lease runs, and who decides

The third open term is renewal. On January 28, 2026, the board heard from leaseholders whose leases had just been renewed for a second 99-year term. One couple's lease now runs to April 30, 2155, and they asked to extend it to 2254. Another leaseholder asked to renew a lease that expires September 29, 2167. Mary Jane Bass advised that leases already renewed once weren't ready for another renewal. Johnson's motions to approve got no second. Childers suggested a 99-year maximum at any one time, so a lease renewed in 2026 would run to 2125 no matter how many years were left.

Staff then brought back a revised Residential Leases and Amendments policy. It would have let leaseholders with like-term renewal rights renew at any time during the current term, with requests due at least six months before expiration. The policy already lists two ways to set a new annual fee when a lease is amended and restated or a fee is negotiable at renewal. One is the original fee adjusted with the federal CPI calculator. The other is the average annual rent across single-family leases. The draft would have added "whichever is greater." At the February 11 committee meeting, Timothy said she saw no need for a renewal policy, and the item died for lack of a motion. The February 25 board minutes record the same result.

Renewals are still decided one request at a time. On April 22, for example, the board unanimously approved a 99-year renewal for Horton Beach Property, LLC at 1008 Ariola Drive.

Renewal isn't the only thing that opens a lease. The draft policy also describes an "Amended and Restated" lease used when a leaseholder asks for something like a development change. The policy lists separate amendments for substantial improvements, for construction below base flood elevation, and for piers. SRIA's 2026 flood outreach letter explains the 50% rule. If improvements or damage repairs cost 50% or more of a building's market value, the structure has to be brought up to current building and floodplain codes. Escambia County requires approval from SRIA's Floodplain Administrator before a beach permit application goes to the county. It also says all work needs SRIA approval, even work the county's permit rules exempt. If you plan a major renovation, the SRIA board will be part of the approval process, along with your architect.

Before you sign: a leasehold checklist

  • The lease itself. Get the full recorded lease and any amendments. Read the fee, the expiration date and the renewal language. SRIA requires that the recorded assignment be provided to the Authority, and the transfer fee depends on the particular lease.
  • Pier documents. For soundfront property, confirm whether a Pier Amendment exists. Ask how any DEP permit showed upland interest.
  • Annual carrying cost. Add the current lease payment, confirmed with SRIA, to the property tax on the improvements.
  • Renovation plans. Find out whether your plans would trigger a lease amendment or SRIA floodplain review before you set a budget.
  • Title coverage. Ask your title agent about a leasehold owner's title policy, which a local title company describes as available for these transactions.

Questions buyers ask

Can I buy the land outright? Not today. Escambia County voters rejected fee simple ownership when it was put to them, as reported by the Pensacola News Journal. In September 2025, Pensacola Beach Advocates president Rhonda Dorfman said the group was working with Congressman Jimmy Patronis on fee simple title and exploring incorporation. Public records through October 2026 show no 2026 bill or vote on either.

Did my fire fee really go away? Under the 2025 interlocal agreement, SRIA took over the cost of Station No. 13. The county beach fire fee was expected to fall to zero beginning in October 2025. Check your current tax bill to confirm it.

Where do I follow these decisions? SRIA posts its agendas and minutes at sria-fla.com. Island Times covers board meetings in detail.

Whether you're buying or selling on Santa Rosa Island, The Mark Lee Team can review a specific lease with you: the fee, the renewal terms and any pier amendment. That way the lease shows up in the price before an offer is written. Request a Complimentary Market Evaluation and bring the lease.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

REAL ESTATE INSIGHTS

Recent Blog Posts

View our latest blog posts about real estate and much more below.

Follow Us On Instagram